Latest topics
» Can you shoot through artillary?
Today at 3:14 am by Gaius Cassius

» Impetuous Mounted Troops and Fortifications
Today at 3:07 am by Gaius Cassius

» Cost of Scotts MAA downgraded to pike
Sun Apr 22, 2018 9:10 am by Geoffrm

» Ignoring Artillery
Thu Apr 19, 2018 9:55 pm by Aurelius

» BI2 tournament - 12 May 2018 - CANCELLED
Thu Apr 19, 2018 11:07 am by Aurelius

» Anyone make custom mats?
Wed Apr 18, 2018 5:15 pm by shakespear

» Retreat After Loosing a Melee
Sat Apr 14, 2018 10:34 pm by Gaius Cassius

» Newbie question
Tue Apr 10, 2018 10:30 am by Zippee

» Basic Impetus Army List - French Wars of Religion
Tue Apr 10, 2018 9:04 am by SnellPoo

BI2 tournament - 12 May 2018 - CANCELLED

Tue Jan 23, 2018 10:26 am by RogerC

EDIT I am very sorry, but I’ve had to CANCEL this tournament. I’ve …

Comments: 8

Vapnartak. Sunday 4th February 2018 Knavesmere Stand York Racecourse

Thu Jan 04, 2018 7:54 am by Cyrus The Adequate

Hi Gents

York is the usual first event in the UK Impetus calendar. This year …

Comments: 28

Basic Impetus 2 Comp, January 2018?

Mon Oct 30, 2017 10:03 am by Aurelius

I've brought the confirmed details for the Basic Impetus competition to the …

Comments: 32

Vapnartak York Feb 2018- format options?

Wed Oct 18, 2017 8:26 am by Cyrus The Adequate

Hi everyone

I was pondering the options for the York competition and wondered …

Comments: 11

Impetus Competition Derby Worlds 2017

Sun Jul 02, 2017 4:42 pm by Cyrus The Adequate

There will be a 28mm Impetus Competition at Derby World Wargames on 7th …

Comments: 47

Impetus at Derby?

Thu Apr 27, 2017 9:29 am by Cyrus The Adequate

Anyone interested ? 7th & 8th October at a new venue - Bruntingthorpe …

Comments: 11

April 2018
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
      1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30      

Calendar Calendar


Shieldwall - Compulsory or Not?

Go down

Shieldwall - Compulsory or Not?

Post by Granicus Gaugamela on Tue Feb 02, 2016 6:14 am

Given the list for Feudal Scots for the York tourney and a question I have been asked again, is forming shieldwall as a reaction compulsory?

I know GC has previously stated it is voluntary, but that seems at odds with the wording in AI

"Some Heavy Infantry can create a Shieldwall as a reaction to a charge or to shooting or as a voluntary action. In the latter, voluntary action case, forming Shieldwall is the only action which is allowed during activation (with the exception of recovery from Disorder). Forming Shieldwall as a reaction to charging or shooting is automatic..."

So AI seems to state that the reaction formations are not voluntary, and also that forming shieldwall as a reaction is automatic.

The mandatory forming of shieldwall would also seem to tie in with Lorenzo's notes that shieldwall was great defensively but a bit of a drag offensively when you want to move.

Further, on the unit pricing formula having shieldwall gives -5 to overall points cost for the unit so it is actually costed as a negative rather than as a benefit.


AI goes on to say " i.e. like evasion, and works in a similar way."

So do we now have to test for forming shieldwall?

Will be interested to hear what the thoughts are.




Granicus Gaugamela
VBU 4
VBU 4

Posts : 443
Reputation : 11
Join date : 2014-05-19

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Shieldwall - Compulsory or Not?

Post by accard on Tue Feb 02, 2016 9:19 am

I thought it was voluntary.

But if you were eligible, and wanted to do it, it was automatic. ie you didnt have to roll for it.(or anything else)

"Like evasion" - I think the wording here predates the changes to evasion where a discipline test was required for all evasions - so I don't think that should be read into it - I think it is just saying that as evasion used to be you could do it if of a eligible type.

But I didn't know about the -5 costing. If it is voluntary wouldn't have though it should make a unit cheaper.

accard
VBU 2
VBU 2

Posts : 78
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2014-09-09

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Shieldwall - Compulsory or Not?

Post by Granicus Gaugamela on Tue Feb 02, 2016 10:10 am

accard wrote:I thought it was voluntary.

But if you were eligible, and wanted to do it, it was automatic. ie you didnt have to roll for it.(or anything else)

"Like evasion"  - I  think the wording here predates the changes to evasion where a discipline test was required for all evasions - so I don't think that should be read into it - I think it is just saying that as evasion used to be you could do it if of a eligible type.

But I didn't know about the -5 costing. If it is voluntary wouldn't have though it should make a unit cheaper.

Agree with you on everything, what ultimately changed my mind (ie that it is compulsory) is the -5 point costing.

Granicus Gaugamela
VBU 4
VBU 4

Posts : 443
Reputation : 11
Join date : 2014-05-19

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Shieldwall - Compulsory or Not?

Post by Gaius Cassius on Tue Feb 02, 2016 6:42 pm

accard gave the same response as I did.

GG, I have the point system in front of me and I don't see any reference to shieldwall. My understanding, based on being part of the discussion on shieldwall when it was proposed, was that it was a free cost (some people even complained about this at the time.) Perhaps you have a more recent version of the point costs. Can you point me to where it is so I can take a look? Thanks!
avatar
Gaius Cassius
VBU 7 h.c.
VBU 7 h.c.

Posts : 807
Reputation : 24
Join date : 2014-05-20
Location : Guelph, Ontario, Canada

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Shieldwall - Compulsory or Not?

Post by starkadder on Tue Feb 02, 2016 10:14 pm

"Voluntary" means I can do it if I like.

The verb structure is "can form" not "must form".

The -5 argument I haven't heard before but is intriguing.

"Automatic" means no test required

Certainly, we were playing it as an involuntary action (compulsory) in the first comps. I don't really know when that changed but it has led to some curious field manoeuvres. 

I still prefer that it be compulsory but the whole thing needs to be clarified. And in short declarative sentences. 

A proper description of the dismounting of mounted infantry (e.g. Vikings and Anglo-Danes) also needs to be made. Do they test as per the stated rules or is it also "automatic" (no test)?
avatar
starkadder
VBU 4
VBU 4

Posts : 303
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2014-05-19
Age : 64
Location : Tahmoor, NSW, Oz

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Shieldwall - Compulsory or Not?

Post by Tarty on Wed Feb 03, 2016 4:39 am

Your not confusing it with the -2 for Schiltron here GG ?
avatar
Tarty
VBU 7 h.c.
VBU 7 h.c.

Posts : 540
Reputation : 9
Join date : 2014-05-19
Location : SYDNEY

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Shieldwall - Compulsory or Not?

Post by Granicus Gaugamela on Thu Feb 04, 2016 5:53 am

Probably am mate, probably am.

Granicus Gaugamela
VBU 4
VBU 4

Posts : 443
Reputation : 11
Join date : 2014-05-19

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Shieldwall - Compulsory or Not?

Post by dadiepiombo on Thu Feb 04, 2016 1:09 pm

No cost for SW.
Voluntary means that you can choose to do so when you are active. Otherwise it can be as a reaction during enemy activation.
avatar
dadiepiombo
Admin
Admin

Posts : 896
Reputation : 33
Join date : 2014-05-15

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Shieldwall - Compulsory or Not?

Post by starkadder on Thu Feb 04, 2016 1:58 pm

To be clear, Lorenzo:

Shieldwall is not an involuntary action (e.g. if a unit is shot at, it doesn't have to go into shieldwall but can stay in an open formation if it wishes) .

I apologise if this sounds obvious but it caused some problems at Cancon.
avatar
starkadder
VBU 4
VBU 4

Posts : 303
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2014-05-19
Age : 64
Location : Tahmoor, NSW, Oz

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Shieldwall - Compulsory or Not?

Post by Gaius Cassius on Thu Feb 04, 2016 9:00 pm

Why are you referring to the concept of "involuntary action" starkadder? I can't find the term used in the AI rule on shieldwall. Did I miss it?

Some Heavy Infantry can create a Shieldwall as a reaction to a charge or to shooting or as a voluntary action. In the latter, voluntary action case, forming Shieldwall is the only action which is allowed during activation (with the exception of recovery from Disorder).

Forming Shieldwall as a reaction to charging or shooting is automatic, i.e. like evasion, and works in a similar way.


avatar
Gaius Cassius
VBU 7 h.c.
VBU 7 h.c.

Posts : 807
Reputation : 24
Join date : 2014-05-20
Location : Guelph, Ontario, Canada

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Shieldwall - Compulsory or Not?

Post by starkadder on Thu Feb 04, 2016 9:27 pm

Because the term "automatic" has been used to justify a local interpretation of the active player (who is opposing a shieldwall army) triggering the reaction so as to slow down its advance. 

Automatic can be inferred as involuntary. The Venus fly-trap, supermarket doors and a Browning pistol all spring to mind. 

I do not agree with this interpretation, Gaius, but it needs to be clubbed down as it has created some discord.
avatar
starkadder
VBU 4
VBU 4

Posts : 303
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2014-05-19
Age : 64
Location : Tahmoor, NSW, Oz

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Shieldwall - Compulsory or Not?

Post by Gaius Cassius on Thu Feb 04, 2016 9:52 pm

The player in question skarkadder is wrong in his interpretation. Automatic refers to action of forming shieldwall once it is chosen. There is no need to pass a DT to form shieldwall. That is what Lorenzo meant above. Shieldwall can be formed in the player's own movement phase (voluntarily) or it can result as a reaction to enemy fire or charge (with certain restrictions.) Like evade the player is not required to avail himself of this ability.

There is nothing that an enemy player facing units that can form shieldwall can do to force this reaction. It is totally at the discretion of the controlling player.

I am a 100% certain about this. I hope for your sakes that Lorenzo responds to confirm this.



avatar
Gaius Cassius
VBU 7 h.c.
VBU 7 h.c.

Posts : 807
Reputation : 24
Join date : 2014-05-20
Location : Guelph, Ontario, Canada

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Shieldwall - Compulsory or Not?

Post by Tarty on Thu Feb 04, 2016 11:13 pm

'Forming Shieldwall as a reaction to charging or shooting
is automatic'

replaced with

'Forming Shieldwall as a reaction to charging or shooting
is also voluntary' ..... would fix this ?

Perhaps take out the reference to evasion ?  probably confuses things Smile
avatar
Tarty
VBU 7 h.c.
VBU 7 h.c.

Posts : 540
Reputation : 9
Join date : 2014-05-19
Location : SYDNEY

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Shieldwall - Compulsory or Not?

Post by Gaius Cassius on Fri Feb 05, 2016 12:50 am

How about,

"Forming Shieldwall as a reaction to charging or shooting is voluntary and is automatic (ie. does not require a discipline test.)"

I think part of the problem is that voluntary probably registers different for Lorenzo who's first language is Italian and us English players.
avatar
Gaius Cassius
VBU 7 h.c.
VBU 7 h.c.

Posts : 807
Reputation : 24
Join date : 2014-05-20
Location : Guelph, Ontario, Canada

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Shieldwall - Compulsory or Not?

Post by starkadder on Fri Feb 05, 2016 1:27 am

Forming Shieldwall is a voluntary action. It does not require a discipline test. It can be formed in reaction to being charged or from shooting."
avatar
starkadder
VBU 4
VBU 4

Posts : 303
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2014-05-19
Age : 64
Location : Tahmoor, NSW, Oz

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Shieldwall - Compulsory or Not?

Post by Tarty on Fri Feb 05, 2016 4:59 am

Yes they're good also. Either would do the job Wink
avatar
Tarty
VBU 7 h.c.
VBU 7 h.c.

Posts : 540
Reputation : 9
Join date : 2014-05-19
Location : SYDNEY

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Shieldwall - Compulsory or Not?

Post by Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum